Copy
April 29, 2022
View this email in your browser
Website
LinkedIn
Facebook
Email

Do the Math

 

One of my most important lessons in communication and advocacy came from His Honour Justice Panet. It’s hugely important for lawyers, but it works for everybody.

Back in the day, the local law association ran an annual event called “This Hour Has Twenty-Two Judges”, a spin on a then popular TV show. Each of the (more or less) twenty-two judges was assigned five minutes to present on a burning topic, with His Honour Colin McKinnon on stopwatch. Behind closed doors, the local bench and bar could get pretty frank, and pretty funny. (And yes, I realize that twenty-two times five minutes is considerably more than an hour, but what can I say?) 

When his turn arrived, Judge Panet spoke about motions court, and in particular, motion briefs. 

A quick word of explanation: “motions” are court proceedings which deal with procedural matters, to seek a ruling to allow or prohibit this or that next step in a legal proceeding. Each lawyer must prepare a “motion brief” setting out the facts, the law, and the argument supporting his or her position.

There are strict limits on the length and structure of the briefs. Regardless, some lawyers flaunt the rules and produce bloated, verbose, and confusing documents-- unbrief briefs, I suppose you could say. If the court doesn’t impose enough discipline, these word salads lead to an inordinate waste of valuable time.

Judge Panet was succinct. His delivery was more or less like this: “Listen, you people, here’s how it works, at least for me.”

“If I’m running motions court the next day, when I get home after a hard day of listening to you guys argue, there is a large box waiting for me, already delivered by courier. In the box are all the motion briefs for the next day.”

“Being late in the day, I’ll treat myself to dinner with my wife, and then I go to my study and open the box. I’m going to give that box two hours, and not a minute more. Now, stay with me while I do the math.”

“Let’s suppose there are twelve matters on the docket, which is average. That means I have an applicant’s brief and a respondent’s brief on each matter, for a total of twenty-four. And I have one hundred and twenty minutes.”

Silence settled over the room, because most lawyers are pretty good at mental math, and they could see where this was going.

“So, if you divide a hundred and twenty minutes by twenty-four, you get five minutes per brief,” Judge Panet confirmed. “And that’s all you get.”

“I set the timer, open the brief, and read for five minutes. Then I put it away, and do the same with the next one. And then the next one. Five minutes, not a second more.”

“Now, a well-written brief says everything you need to say, and more, in those five minutes. So if you choose to ramble on, and on, and on, that’s your prerogative, but you’re only getting five minutes of my time. What you say after five minutes remains unread.”

Justice Panet kept within his allotted five minutes, and from that day forward, I timed my motion briefs. And kept them brief.

The lesson is not just for lawyers.

 

Forward to a friend


Please help! I'm looking to double readership numbers, which means that if every reader successfully invites one friend, we're done! Just send them a quick note including this link. I'd be most grateful.


Can I help you or your organization? Contact me at norm@purposeful.ca or at 613-862-3489. 


Friday Briefing Archives

 

An Ask. For Money. For a Wonderful Cause.

Over the years I was heavily involved with the Ottawa Hospital Foundation, and we put Ottawa on the map with world-class research and facilities. Now a more ambitious project: a brand new, world class facility. Your help can go a long way.

I’ve never been able to feel that there is anything undignified about making your living by the sweat of your brow.

Read more at: https://www.idlehearts.com/97442/ive-never-been-able-to-feel-that-there-is-anything-undignified-about-making-your-living-by-the-sweat-of-your-brow
Source: IdleHearts
I’ve never been able to feel that there is anything undignified about making your living by the sweat of your brow.

Read more at: https://www.idlehearts.com/97442/ive-never-been-able-to-feel-that-there-is-anything-undignified-about-making-your-living-by-the-sweat-of-your-brow
Source: IdleHearts

Blessed is the man, who having nothing to say, abstains from giving wordy evidence of the fact.

George Eliot (Pen name of Mary Ann Evans)

What I Do

I am an explainer, that is, I deconstruct complexity and re-frame it in understandable terms.

In particular, I explain the secrets of professional success-- things I wish I had known as a beginner lawyer in 1981, but which I had to learn by trial and error (and the occasional epiphany).

Simple yet profound, these secrets are really just specific applications of common-sense life lessons. They are the keys to true professional satisfaction and financial success.

Call me at 613-862-3489 or e-mail me at norm@purposeful.ca

 
 
© Norman Bowley 2022, all rights reserved.
Your privacy is important to me. I never rent, sell, share your email address – ever!

This e-mail is coming to your in-box because you subscribed. If it just shows up without permission, please scold it, delete it, and tell us. We support and do our absolute best not to offend the Canadian Anti-Spam Legislation (CASL), more formally known as "An Act to promote the efficiency and adaptability of the Canadian economy by regulating certain activities that discourage reliance on electronic means of carrying out commercial activities, and to amend the Canadian Radio-television and Telecommunications Commission Act, the Competition Act, the Personal Information Protection and Electronic Documents Act and the Telecommunications Act." If you tell us that we sent this e-mail to you in error, your name will be struck from our list in an instant, with our abject apologies.

You can update your preferences or unsubscribe from this list.


 






This email was sent to <<Email Address>>
why did I get this?    unsubscribe from this list    update subscription preferences
Purposeful Communications · 239 Somerville Drive · Perth, Ontario K7H 3C6 · Canada

Email Marketing Powered by Mailchimp