July 28, 2016 | Podcast | Open in Browser


Killing is Never Medical Care
The Democratic Party Is More Extreme on Abortion Than Ever
Being a priest has become a dangerous job
Do College Students Believe in Religious Freedom?

Killing is Never Medical Care

We talk a lot about physician-prescribed death in this publication, and with good reason. But little is as convicting or powerful as the testimony of physicians who are extremely concerned about the rise of patient-killing.

From The Wall Street Journal:

"I am an oncologist/hematologist who has been practicing in California, primarily at Eisenhower Medical Center in Rancho Mirage, for 39 years. It has been my privilege to have treated and cared for more than 16,000 patients with cancer or blood diseases and to have provided pain relief and comfort for the dying.

"I am also one of six concerned physicians who, along with the American Academy of Medical Ethics, have sued in a California Superior Court to try to block as unconstitutional the state’s Physician Assisted Suicide law, which went into effect on June 9. More recently, a group of doctors and health-care professionals in Vermont joined a lawsuit filed July 19 to try to block the way that state’s 2013 assisted suicide law is being interpreted and misapplied."

The concern with the way the law is "being interpreted and misapplied" is this: "The law does not require an attending physician to refer the patient for psychological assessment." So even if you believe that killing a patient is the most "compassionate" course of action, there is currently no screening process in California to prevent coercion or detect other mental conditions that may lead a person to wish death upon themselves.

The author continues:

"On the day that physician-assisted suicide was legalized, my hospital and the other local hospitals announced that they were opting out and would not facilitate the killing of any patients. Some local hospices informed me that they would continue to give palliative care, instead of helping patients kill themselves.

"Killing is never medical care. There is no circumstance when any compassionate, competent physician would prescribe a deadly drug to any patient. If 'medical practice' has any meaning, it definitely does not include using drugs to willfully kill a patient or for a physician and pharmacist to supply a lethal drug so that a patient can kill himself."

We repeat: "Killing is never medical care." This is, in fact, why the abortion debate is often wrapped up in the personhood of the unborn child; if the unborn child is a person, then "terminating" it is killing it, which disqualifies it as "medical care."

Let's return to a comment above, that some believe that "killing a patient is the most 'compassionate' course of action."

We've heard that time and time again, along with the "death with dignity" rhetoric.

Over at the Regina Leader-Post, Brett Salkeld talks a little bit about this concept of compassion, and how incompatible it truly is with killing patients:

"While public debates and court cases tend to be won on the most difficult cases, we worry that once suicide has been deemed the answer to the suffering of some it will be nearly impossible to deny that it can be the answer to the suffering of others. None of us wants to be in the position to tell someone that her or his suffering is not up to the standard that we set for assisted suicide.

"But we must also admit that most of us are not simply against assisted suicide because of the potential for it to become much more common than imagined in initial public discussion. We are also against assisted suicide in the hardest cases, in those cases where the suffering is undeniably immense. And we would continue to be against it even if we believed that safeguards could be put in place to prevent the expansion of assisted suicide. Why?"

Salkeld goes on to argue that if we decide to end the lives of those who are suffering, we actively lose out on an opportunity to develop compassion in ourselves. His analogy for this is the integration of severely disabled students in classrooms, which may not teach the disabled students math or English, but certainly teaches other students about living with and near those who are suffering. In the same way, if we banish the infirm, elderly, or otherwise disabled to death, we will struggle to learn how to extend compassion to those who are suffering in our day-to-day lives.

The whole post is certainly worth reading.

On the Blog

See More Blogs

Can Healthcare Professionals Prescribe Death and Keep Their Oath to "Do No Harm?"

"Alliance Defending Freedom attorneys have filed suit in federal court against medical licensing authorities in Vermont on behalf of health care professionals who wish to abide by their oath to "do no harm." The state agencies are construing Vermont's assisted suicide law as requiring them, regardless of their conscience or oath, to counsel patients on doctor-prescribed death as an option."

by Bob Trent

On Our Nation’s Campuses, the Great Struggle Goes On

"The struggle for the soul of America – an epic, nation-shaping conflict often referred to as “the Culture Wars” – has been fought on many battlefields: in the courts, in the media, in the culture, in the churches, on TV and movie screens. But no ground has been harder fought on, or fought over, than our nation’s schools."

by Alan Sears

Latest News Releases

See More Releases

Christian law school standing strong after win at Nova Scotia Court of Appeals
Alaska Supreme Court: Parents can be left in dark when child seeks abortion
Colorado cake artist asks US Supreme Court to protect his freedom of expression
ADF in the News

Alaska Supreme Court strikes down abortion parental notification law for minors
Christian Today
Christian baker asks U.S. Supreme Court to intervene in same-sex discrimination case
Christian Today
Virginia’s largest school district halts Obama’s unisex restroom/shower policy
Life Site News
Alaska Supreme Court: Parents have no rights regarding minor daughters’ abortions
Live Action News
The long— and sometimes surprising — history behind the IRS ban on churches endorsing political candidates
The Oklahoman
US Christian baker takes case to Supreme Court
The Christian Institute
Churches & Political Activity: The Call to Repeal the Johnson Amendment
Nonprofit Quarterly
More News

Only Miles From Democrat Convention, Kermit Gosnell’s Clinic Brings Abortion Industry Horrors to Forefront
The Daily Signal
Religious people oppose genetic engineering to enhance human abilities
Christian Today
France in shock again after Isis murder of priest in Normandy
The Guardian
Greece eyes constitution overhaul, more space between Orthodox Church and state
Government Definition Of ‘Extremism’ Is Too Wide, Says Key Human Rights Committee
Rights Info
Hate crime guidance for prosecutors to deal with social media
The Law Society Gazette
New video exposes the truth about third trimester abortions
Live Action News
Scottish agencies in drive to increase gay adoption
The Christian Institute
#RepealThe8th goes viral after Dublin City Council order Irish abortion campaign mural to be removed
The Irish Post
Planned Parenthood responds to decision to drop all charges against the Center for Medical Progress
Live Action News
Being a priest has become a dangerous job
The Spectator
The Democratic Party Is More Extreme on Abortion Than Ever
ParentsDolly’s clones ageing no differently to naturally-conceived sheep, study finds
The Guardian
Controversial religious procession barred from entering Kiev
Associated Press
Religious Vilification claim in Victoria rejected
Law and Religion Australia
Religious Freedom victory in Nova Scotia
Law and Religion Australia
Protective security for Christian places of worship
Law & Religion UK
Schools may have to reduce teaching time for religion
The Irish Times
Administration: Single-Payer System Stops Religious Freedom Challenges to Abortifacient Mandate
CNS News
Federal Judge: HHS Contraceptive Mandate Violates Religious Freedom
Church Militant
Leaked e-mails show DNC meetings with anti-religious freedom project
Catholic News Agency
Proponents of Proposed Assisted Suicide Bill Perpetuate Myths
Intermountain Catholic
Do College Students Believe in Religious Freedom?
Take Part
Physician-assisted suicide opposes faith, says leading bioethics expert
Vermont physicians resist assisted suicide mandate
Becker's Hospital Review
Planned Parenthood Uses Virtual Reality to Promote Abortion at Democrat Convention
The Daily Signal
Undercover Filmmaker Who Exposed Planned Parenthood Calls His Case a ‘Huge Win’ for Journalists
The Daily Signal
George Washington’s Constitutional Morality
Public Discourse
For Many Christians in Middle East, Intimidation or Worse
The Wall Street Journal